In any
discussion about using military force as part of an attempt at humanitarian
intervention in order to prevent genocide and human rights abuses, there are a
series of issues to be examined. First, there is the question of legitimacy. Is
there a clear mandate from the UN Security Council? If there is not, should
countries act without it if there is widespread support in the UN General Assembly?
Then there is the question of effectiveness. Do such missions usually achieve
their basic goal of bringing peace and stability and ending the violence, or do
they lead to more violence? Is the mission welcomed by the local people
involved? (Compare for example: Somalia, Afghanistan and Libya) Moreover, would
the funds used for the mission be better spent elsewhere as direct aid on a
more concrete problem? (e.g. on providing food, water, medicine and shelter to
an area not requiring a military presence). There is another important
consideration that is often raised. Many experts argue that since the
foundation of the UN humanitarian intervention has always been 'politicized'.
What exactly the international community should do in response to the situation
in Syria, for example, cannot be debated 'neutrally', simply as a humanitarian
crisis. Each member state of the UNSC and the UNGA will inevitably bring to the
discussion its own economic and strategic interests, and its own cultural or
ideological perspective. In international relations this is the normal context
in which a diplomatic discussion of a question like that of Syria takes place.
In order to
respond to a question like:
What are the main factors to be weighed when the international community is considering military intervention in response to a humanitarian crisis?
you need to look at these sources and think about the
ideas raised in relation to past and present humanitarian crises and
intervention or non-intervention by the international community:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Responsibility_to_protect
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Responsibility_to_protect
Nessun commento:
Posta un commento
Nota. Solo i membri di questo blog possono postare un commento.